The narrator in Poe's classic short story "The Tell-Tale Heart" is completely unreliable and is clearly mentally unstable. In the first paragraph of the story, there is a litany of clues that reveal the narrator's unreliability. The narrator uses staccato speech, which is typical of an extremely nervous, paranoid individual. The fact that he is attempting to persuade the reader that he is not mad is also suspicious. Why would a sane individual need to convince someone that they are not crazy? In addition to the narrator's staccato speech and insistence on his sanity, the narrator mentions that he can hear all things in heaven and hell, which is both disturbing and indicative of a mentally unstable person.
The narrator proceeds to contradict himself: he claims that he loved the old man, while simultaneously plotting his murder. The narrator's motivation for killing the old man is also suspicious, as he insists that the old man's Evil Eye is the source of his rage. He also believes that he can understand the old man's thoughts and read his mind. At this point in the story, the reader understands that the narrator is both mentally ill and unreliable. After describing the horrific way he murdered and dismembered the old man, the narrator proceeds to insist that he could hear the old man's heart beating from beneath the floorboards. The reader understands that the narrator's conscience has affected his mind and that he is overwhelmed with guilt. However, the narrator insists that he is audibly hearing the dead man's heartbeat, which reveals his insanity. The fact that the narrator presents a distorted view of reality and contradicts himself several times proves that he is unreliable.
In "The Tell-Tale Heart," the narrator tries to convince the reader that he is sane. However, as he tells his story, it becomes clear that he is indeed suffering from some mental instability. As a result, he is not a reliable narrator because his version of events is influenced by his state of mind, making it difficult for the reader to trust what he says.
The narrator, for example, clearly suffers from paranoia. He believes that the old man has an "evil eye" that delights in torturing him. Moreover, the narrator also believes that he is capable of reading the old man's mind. He thinks he knows what the old man is thinking and feeling. This is shown clearly when, on the night of the murder, the narrator claims that the old man thinks he can hear the wind in the chimney or a mouse crossing the floor.
The narrator, therefore, presents a distorted version of events, and this affects the reliability of his narration.
No comments:
Post a Comment