Howard Zinn (August 24, 1922 – January 27, 2010) was an historian and political scientist with a PhD in history from Columbia University who had a long and distinguished career as a professor. As well as his popular works, he published scholarship in peer-reviewed journals. These qualifications suggest that his work will generally be factually accurate in the sense that he will get dates correct, spell names correctly, and be a generally reliable recounter of empirical information; he won't make the sort of errors that a high school student would make. That doesn't mean his interpretations of the events he discusses should be taken as anything more than one thinker's understanding of those events.
Interpretation is not a matter of trustworthiness but of persuasiveness. Zinn has a particular political stance and interprets events through that lens. As he is an influential and original thinker, his ideas are worth serious consideration. One should never, though, "trust" interpretations wholesale, but one should think for oneself, reading a wide range of different interpretations and primary materials, and then basing one's thinking about history on careful and judicious examination and reflection of multiple viewpoints rather than blind trust of some one individual.
A People's History of the United States is a popular textbook rather than a work of scholarship, and thus it tends to generalize more than works written for an audience of specialists. Thus although it makes for an interesting introductory text, that is not the same as meticulous scholarship that attempts authoritative treatment of a specific, narrow issue.
Sunday, February 24, 2019
Do you trust Zinn? Why or why not?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Summarize the major research findings of "Toward an experimental ecology of human development."
Based on findings of prior research, the author, Bronfenbrenner proposes that methods for natural observation research have been applied in ...
-
One way to support this thesis is to explain how these great men changed the world. Indeed, Alexander the Great (356–323 BC) was the quintes...
-
Polysyndeton refers to using several conjunctions in a row to achieve a dramatic effect. That can be seen in this sentence about the child: ...
-
Both boys are very charismatic and use their charisma to persuade others to follow them. The key difference of course is that Ralph uses his...
-
At the most basic level, thunderstorms and blizzards are specific weather phenomena that occur most frequently within particular seasonal cl...
-
Equation of a tangent line to the graph of function f at point (x_0,y_0) is given by y=y_0+f'(x_0)(x-x_0). The first step to finding eq...
-
Population policy is any kind of government policy that is designed to somehow regulate or control the rate of population growth. It include...
-
Gulliver cooperates with the Lilliputians because he is so interested in them. He could, obviously, squash them underfoot, but he seems to b...
No comments:
Post a Comment