Holden's use of the term phony defines any adolescent or adult who is superficial, competitive, and insincere. Holden is portrayed as a hypercritical, neurotic teenager who is extremely judgmental and believes that the simplest forms of insincerity make a person phony. For example, Holden labels his teacher Mr. Spencer a phony for laughing at the headmaster’s jokes and behaving differently while he is being observed by his boss. Despite Mr. Spencer's favorable attributes, which portray him as a concerned, genuine man, Holden judges him for acting phony despite the situation.
It is fair to say that Holden labels the vast majority of people he interacts with as phonies, which include Stradlater, the women at the Lavender Room, Sally Hayes, and his own brother, D.B. Only a select few characters are depicted as alternatives to phonies. These characters are Allie, Phoebe, Jane Gallagher, James Castle, and the two nuns he interacts with on Sunday morning. These characters are depicted as innocent, vulnerable individuals. As an insecure, naive adolescent, Holden identifies with these types of people and is attracted to them. Therefore, the alternatives to phonies Holden offers in the story are sensitive, vulnerable individuals like himself. As a traumatized, insecure teenager, Holden is not prepared to enter the competitive world of adults and feels more comfortable interacting with children and sensitive adults.
I am not exactly sure what you mean by “alternatives” to phoniness, but I’m going to try my best to answer your question. Holden Caulfield, the main character in Catcher in the Rye, is obsessed with phoniness. He sees phoniness all around him, and he considers phony to be anything that is hypocritical, superficial, or inauthentic in any way, such as anything that is done or said for the sake of appearances rather than to express genuine thoughts and feelings.
Holden thinks all adults are phony, and thus he struggles to grow up and hesitates to join the world of adulthood. Because he believes that only in the state of innocence can people be genuine, he sees innocence as the opposite of phoniness. Therefore, the only alternative to phoniness is to remain a child and preserve that state of innocence. Phoebe’s childhood innocence is what Holden admires most about her. In his view, her actions and responses to him show that she is in large part untainted by society, and it distresses him tremendously to see how the outside world—the adult world—corrupts that innocence and puts Phoebe at the risk of becoming phony, too. For this reason, Holden wants to be the catcher in the rye: he wants to catch children before they fall off the cliff into the world of adulthood and phoniness.
Holden has a couple of favorite substitutes for "phony." He describes Stradlater, his roommate, as "a phony kind of friendly" and later, as a guy who thinks of himself as a real "hot-shot." In this case, Holden's ironic tone is the substitute for phony, as his sarcastic description of Stradlater conveys his scorn. He also refers to Stradlater as a "bastard," which is another effective substitute for "phony."
Sometimes, Holden prefers to supplement "phony" with other words like "bastard" and use both insults together to communicate a more intense than normal disrespect for a person. For example, Holden describes a man named Ossenberger, whose name memorializes the new wing of the dorms at Pencey, as a "big phony bastard" when Ossenberger comes to Pencey expecting accolades.
No comments:
Post a Comment